A Critique Of The British Crime Survey

The exclusion of the under 16 age group in the survey has raised concern from both the NSPCC and several other children"tms charities, that a great deal of crime against a vulnerable group is being missed and unreported. Genn (1982) also suggests that sexual and domestic crimes are under-reported in the BCS, however new touch screen computers for such incidents may help alleviate this concern. The survey sample for the BCS is collected from the postcode address file (PAF), which is in turn drawn up from the national census. Although the census is meant to be compulsory, the numbers of uncompleted census forms are increasing. Thus not all the population eligible to be included in the BCS will be included, these discrepancies do not fall into the realms of sampling error, as the numbers involved are relatively small in comparison to the overall survey. Comparisons between the sample proportions and the census proportions are therefore seen as a valid method of testing the validity and representativeness of the BCS sampling survey. The BCS has been criticised by Genn et al


 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Crime and Punishment
Crime and Punishment: Getting Off amp39amp39The Hookamp39amp39Repercussions ... on.Thoreau is harsh in his critique of soldiers ... being thrown in a British prison, amp39amp39All ... (290112
  
Japanese Internment
... been found guilty of the same crime. Those ... of the Japanese Canadians, 1942: A Realist Critique of the ... feeling was not particularly intense in British Columbia ... (15736
  
Japanese Internment
... war without one ever being charged with any crime. ... The Japanese community in British Columbia showed a ... of the Japanese Canadian, 1942: Realist Critique of the ... (22299
  
music adolescent
... the masterminds of newaged crime law enforcement ... in the Organization of Thieving,British Journal of ... 5. Smith, G A Constitutional Critique of Carnivore ... (18768
  
The Begger
... deserve to continue their life of crime because they ... Gay has quite brilliantly inverted British Eighteenth Century ... to launch a scathing social critique upon a ... (17697
  
 
 
 


Another criticism of the BCS was argued by Hazel Genn (1988) who pointed out the deficient way the BCS records "multiple victimization"tm. She pointed out that the BCS only allows up to six separate crimes to be recorded on each survey. This meant that multiple crimes such as domestic abuse and persistent harassment could only be counted as six crimes, and the rest were put together as one crime. These disparities were first highlighted by Spark (1977) in the recording of police statistics, and point to a "dark figure"tm of crime which may in some circumstances be as much as eleven times higher than the official figures.

Another major flaw in the BCS is the categorisation of crime; a minor or petty crime is counted equally as a major crime in the final statistics. This anomaly was pointed out by (Sellin and Wolfgang 1966) who created a weighted index for crime. They argued that by counting all crime as equitable, the perception of overall crime would become distorted. The perception of crime is something that cannot be addressed in a questionnaire-based survey. The perception of crime affects more people than crime itself. The fear of crime for the most vulnerable in society can mean a dramatic loss of quality of life.

The BCS is far from a perfect research tool, it has many flaws with the collection and presentation of the collected data. It does give a more accurate representation of the total numbers of crimes being committed than police figures, however the severity of many of these crimes is open to closer scrutiny. The politicisation of the BCS has also meant that many people have lost faith in the whole survey. All parties pick and choose aspects of the survey, which suit the hot topic of the day. There seems to be no better way of collating so much data quickly than using a questionnaire based survey, it may be possible to use the internet with secure passwords, however this is open to the same bias and demand characteristics as the current survey.

The survey sample for the






1355
5
 
 

PROFESSIONAL ESSAYS
 
The New Federalism: A CritiqueThe New Federalism: A Critique. ... the original geographic charters granted by the British Crown ... Once the province of Nevadans and organized crime, state lotteries ... (3023 12 )

Legalizing Prostitution... as criminal assault, rape and unnatural crime." And in ... own women: A Thirteenth Amendment critique of forced ... London: British Association of Libertarian Feminists ... (951 4 )

Sociological Models of Deviance Theory The purpose of this ...... in this context that Jones's critique of traditional ... The British Journal of Sociology, 26, 52 65 ... The crime of precocious sexuality: female juvenile delinquency ... (2828 11 )

Mandatory Periodical Sources... Ethics Critical Care Nursing Quarterly Critique: Studies in ... Journal of Sociology; Andover British Medical Journal ... Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency ... (8266 33 )

Aggression in Men and Women... reported having consciously imitated crime techniques learned ... Critique Although there is some evidence for a ... British Journal of Psychology, 82, 28- (incomplete ... (2095 8 )

Expressive Individualism in America... As critique of social scientism, advocates human-centered ... consciousness is implied explanation of British respect for ... the threat of organized crime and how ... (5294 21 )

 
 

 
Join Now
     
  Get instant access to over
85,000 Term papers and
Essays.
 
     
 
 
     
 
 
Saved Papers
 

Save your essays here so you can locate them quickly!


 
 
 
Testimonials
 
 
"This website is very helpful and informative and well worth it's money. Thanks!"
Sean R.
 
"it really helps me get different point of views on some essay subjects."
Steve D.
 
"I got the best grade I've ever gotten A+"
Mary P.
 
"This information was helpful and easy to find."
Kris DD.
 
"This site is so helpful! You have opened my eyes to learning thank you!"
Karen F.
 
 
 
 
 
 
Home | Custom Essays | Join | FAQs | Support | Acceptable Use Policy
 
All papers are for research and reference purposes only!
Copyright © 2002-2013 RAD Essays.com. All Rights Reserved. DMCA HMS