Instant Access To 100,000+ Essays!

Hypothesis: Due to the dubious and unproved value as a deterrent to violent crime, the inequity and mistakes inevitable in any system of justice instituted and administered by fallible human beings and the degrading and hurtful impulse toward retribution and revenge that it expresses, the abolition of capital punishment should be still maintained in Australian society. Violent crime abhors most of us, and outrages our sense of morality. But more than that, it offends our sense of safety and well being within our communities. It tears at the very fabric of society. For many, the response to crimes of a violent nature is calls to "get tough on crime". (Philips,J.H,1987) Some years ago, former West Australian Premier Richard Court mooted the idea of the reintroduction of the death penalty in Australia for violent crimes. The logic is essentially, "you killed someone, so we'll kill you". Some call on religious authority- "an eye for an eye." (Opas, P.1996) There's a big problem with this logic. Proponents of the death penalty claim ownership of the moral high ground in their arguments regarding murder, rape and other crimes. They claim the violence and immorality of the crime gives them a right to demand that they be able to do the